Housing market · ZIP 11965

Shelter Island Heights, NY Home Prices & Forecast

Median value and 12-month outlook · as of April 2026

Median home value

$2,025,914

3-month+0.6%

6-month+2.0%

12-month+5.1%

Touse 12-month forecast

+4.5%

Projected median near $2,116,583 over the next 12 months

As of April 2026, the median home value in Shelter Island Heights, NY (ZIP 11965) is $2,025,914. Prices are rising, up 5.1% over the past year. Touse's model projects a +4.5% change over the next 12 months, putting the median near $2,116,583.

See what you can afford here →

Nearby areas in Suffolk

Holtsville 00501 Holtsville 00544 Fishers Island 06390 Amityville 11701 Babylon 11702 North Babylon 11703 West Babylon 11704 Bayport 11705

Estimates are derived from Zillow Research price history and Touse's forecasting model (LightGBM + Prophet). Forecasts are 12-month projections with inherent uncertainty, not guarantees, and are not financial advice. Confirm with a licensed professional before any decision.