Housing market · ZIP 11953
Middle Island, NY Home Prices & Forecast
Median value and 12-month outlook · as of April 2026
Median home value
$494,176
3-month+1.3%
6-month+2.4%
12-month+4.2%
Touse 12-month forecast
+4.5%
Projected median near $516,272 over the next 12 months
As of April 2026, the median home value in Middle Island, NY (ZIP 11953) is $494,176. Prices are stable, up 4.2% over the past year. Touse's model projects a +4.5% change over the next 12 months, putting the median near $516,272.
Nearby areas in Suffolk
Estimates are derived from Zillow Research price history and Touse's forecasting model (LightGBM + Prophet). Forecasts are 12-month projections with inherent uncertainty, not guarantees, and are not financial advice. Confirm with a licensed professional before any decision.